Illustration for: McKinsey: Enterprise AI ROI Still Lags Adoption Hype

McKinsey: Enterprise AI ROI Still Lags Adoption Hype

McKinsey's 2026 State of AI survey of 1,719 leaders found just 37% attribute any EBIT impact to AI, flat from 2025, while only 6% qualify as 'AI high performers' -- even as AI spending keeps climbing.

By the Numbers

1,719 leaders
Survey size
37%
Report any EBIT impact from AI
6%
'AI high performers'
40% (up from 27%)
Scaling AI agents ($1B+ rev cos.)
39% (up from 32%)
Expect AI-driven job cuts
TC
By the AI Desk
Edited by Trace Cohen · Early-stage VC & angel · Founder, New York Venture Partners
1 min read
ShareXLinkedInEmail

THE RUNDOWN

1

McKinsey's 2026 State of AI survey of 1,719 professionals and business leaders found 37% attribute at least some EBIT impact to AI use, unchanged from 2025, [The Register reported](https://www.theregister.com/ai-and-ml/2026/08/25/mckinsey-says-enterprise-ai-is-finally-on-the-road-to-roi/5292388)

2

Only 6% of respondents qualify as 'AI high performers' -- attributing 5%-plus of organizational EBIT to AI with significant impact -- also flat year over year despite continued spending increases

3

80% of AI users report improved individual productivity, but McKinsey found those gains haven't translated into measurable organizational financial benefit at anywhere near the same rate

4

39% of respondents now expect AI-driven job cuts, up from 32% in 2025, even though McKinsey notes actual 2025 workforce reductions fell well short of the prior year's predictions

TC

The VC Read · Trace's Take

Trace Cohen

The number that should worry anyone pitching enterprise AI ROI to a board right now is that the 6% 'high performer' figure hasn't moved at all year over year despite a jump from 27% to 40% in large companies scaling agents -- spending is accelerating faster than results are materializing, which is exactly the gap that eventually forces a spending correction. I'd want any enterprise AI startup's pitch deck to show a customer's actual EBIT trend line, not just adoption or seat-count growth, before treating their ROI claims as representative.

Analysis

McKinsey's 2026 State of AI report, based on a survey of 1,719 professionals and business leaders globally, found that 37% of respondents attribute at least some EBIT impact to AI use -- unchanged from the 2025 survey -- while only 6% qualify as "AI high performers," defined as organizations attributing 5% or more of EBIT to AI with significant impact, also flat year over year, The Register reported.

  • 37% -- share reporting any EBIT impact from AI, unchanged from 2025
  • 6% -- share qualifying as "AI high performers," also flat
  • 80% -- AI users reporting improved individual productivity
  • 20% -- cite AI operating costs as a constraint on further AI use
  • 40% -- share of $1B-plus revenue companies scaling AI agents, up sharply from 27%
  • 39% -- expect AI-driven job cuts, up from 32% in 2025

The gap between the 80% reporting individual productivity gains and the much smaller 37% seeing organizational financial impact is the report's central tension: McKinsey states plainly that "organizations' conviction in AI is growing faster than the immediate financial returns they can attribute to it." Spending keeps climbing regardless -- the share of large companies scaling AI agents jumped from 27% to 40% year over year -- even as the EBIT-impact numbers refuse to move.

The job-cuts expectation trend is worth separating from actual outcomes: 39% of respondents now expect AI-driven headcount reductions, up from 32% last year, but McKinsey notes actual 2025 workforce reductions came in well short of the prior year's predictions, meaning the anticipation of AI-driven layoffs is consistently running ahead of realized ones. Nearly one-third of surveyed companies chose to build AI coding tools in-house rather than buy software, a build-versus-buy split relevant to any startup selling into enterprise AI tooling budgets.

ShareXLinkedInEmail

Key Sources

2 sources

THE WIRE in your inbox— Tech, startup & VC news with Trace's take. Free, no spam.